The CFTC, the states, and prediction markets: who actually regulates what
A federal derivatives regulator says event contracts are its jurisdiction. State gambling regulators disagree. The unresolved fight is the single biggest risk variable in the category.
Note, November 15, 2026: this analysis was written in May 2026. Figures in it are estimates that we have not traced to a primary source, and some details have changed since. For current rules and status, see our regulation news and state table.
TL;DR:
Prediction-market platforms in the US operate under federal CFTC oversight as Designated Contract Markets. State gambling regulators — backed by tribal gaming interests and incumbent sportsbooks — argue that event contracts on sporting outcomes are gambling and therefore fall under state law. The conflict is now in federal court. Until the Supreme Court rules (or Congress acts), every operator is exposed to whichever interpretation prevails in their jurisdiction.
- Kalshi is regulated by the CFTC as a Designated Contract Market under the Commodity Exchange Act.
- Polymarket settled with the CFTC in 2022; its US affiliate operates under a separate registration.
- At least 12 US states have issued cease-and-desist letters challenging Kalshi's sports contracts.
- The legal theory under contest: do CFTC-registered event contracts federally preempt state gambling law?
- Investors should model two scenarios — federal preemption upheld, and state authority upheld — and stress-test both.
Two regulators, one product
The regulatory ambiguity in US prediction markets exists because two different bodies of law plausibly apply to the same product.
Federal law (Commodity Exchange Act) gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission jurisdiction over derivatives, including "event contracts" that pay based on an underlying occurrence. Kalshi is a CFTC-registered Designated Contract Market (DCM) — the same regulatory status held by CME and ICE.
State gambling law typically defines gambling as risking something of value on a game of chance or future contingent event. Every US state has its own gambling regulator (the New Jersey DGE, the Nevada Gaming Control Board, and so on). Sports betting is licensed state-by-state under these regimes.
The product question is straightforward: when a user pays $0.55 for a contract that pays $1.00 if the Chiefs win, is that a derivative trade (CFTC) or a sports wager (state regulator)?
The legal theory
Kalshi's argument rests on federal preemption. The Commodity Exchange Act grants the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over the listing and trading of derivatives on registered markets. If a state attempts to apply its gambling law to a CFTC-registered event contract, Kalshi argues, that state law is preempted by federal law and is unenforceable.
State regulators counter that:
- The CFTC has discretion under §5c(c)(5)(C) of the Commodity Exchange Act to prohibit event contracts on gaming and certain other enumerated categories, which implies states retain a residual interest.
- Event contracts on sporting outcomes serve no economic-hedging function, which is the historical justification for derivatives regulation.
- Allowing federal preemption here would effectively legalise sports betting nationally without an act of Congress, bypassing two decades of state-led policy choices.
This is not a frivolous dispute. Both sides have credible legal theories. The Supreme Court has not yet weighed in.
The cease-and-desist wave
Starting in late 2024 and accelerating through 2025, gambling regulators in at least a dozen states — including New Jersey, Nevada, Massachusetts, and Ohio — issued cease-and-desist letters demanding that Kalshi delist sports event contracts in their jurisdictions.
Kalshi has responded by filing federal lawsuits, arguing preemption and seeking injunctions blocking state enforcement. At time of writing, the cases are at various stages — some have produced preliminary injunctions in Kalshi's favour, others have not.
The Third Circuit and the Ninth Circuit have heard arguments on overlapping questions. A Supreme Court grant of certiorari is widely expected in the 2026–2027 term. Until then, the operator's ability to offer sports contracts in any given state depends on which court has spoken most recently.
The Polymarket position
Polymarket is structurally different. After a 2022 CFTC consent order, Polymarket geofenced US users and operated offshore. In 2025, it returned to the US market via a regulated affiliate (acquired and integrated into a CFTC-registered structure), but the asset base, settlement layer (USDC on Polygon), and primary user base remain non-US.
The practical effect: Polymarket's regulatory risk is less acute than Kalshi's on the sports-contract front, but its dependence on crypto rails creates a different risk surface — banking access, stablecoin regulation, and Treasury/OFAC interpretations.
The tribal-gaming dimension
US tribal gaming compacts grant federally recognised tribes exclusive or near-exclusive rights to certain forms of gambling within their states. Several tribal coalitions have intervened in the Kalshi litigation, arguing that federal preemption of state law over event contracts would also impair tribal compact rights.
This is a politically powerful constituency. It has historically been able to block sports-betting legalisation in states like California. Any judicial or legislative resolution will need to address tribal sovereignty, not just state regulators.
Three scenarios investors should model
Scenario A: Federal preemption upheld. The Supreme Court rules (or the CFTC formalises by rule) that registered event contracts preempt state gambling law. Kalshi and similar platforms gain national distribution. Sports-betting operators face a competitive product with structurally lower regulatory cost. Valuations of prediction-market venues re-rate upward; valuations of pure-play state-licensed sportsbooks compress.
Scenario B: State authority upheld. Courts or Congress reaffirm that sporting-event contracts are gambling and fall under state law. Kalshi must either delist sports contracts, pursue state licences, or restructure. The category continues to grow in non-sports verticals (politics, finance, weather), but at a slower pace.
Scenario C: Negotiated compromise. Congress passes legislation creating a defined regulatory regime for event contracts — possibly carving out sports for state jurisdiction while permitting federal regulation of non-sports markets. Most operators survive; clarity itself unlocks the next leg of growth.
We assign meaningful probability to all three. The honest answer is that nobody knows.
Implications for media properties
For an affiliate or media business sitting outside the venue layer:
- Regulatory risk is much lower than at the platform. An affiliate that drives traffic to multiple venues across multiple jurisdictions is not the entity facing the cease-and-desist.
- Editorial credibility is an asset. Readers and search engines reward properties that explain regulatory complexity accurately, with primary sources.
- Diversification matters. Routing traffic to sportsbooks, regulated prediction markets, and (where appropriate) DFS or skill-gaming operators reduces dependence on any single regulatory outcome.
This is part of why we believe the media and affiliate layer is the most attractive risk-adjusted entry point into the prediction-markets thesis. We make that case in full in our thesis.
The EU resolved its equivalent question two decades ago: peer-to-peer betting exchanges are licensed by the same regulators as sportsbooks. The UK Gambling Commission, Malta's MGA, and Sweden's SGA each license exchanges under standard gambling frameworks — there is no CFTC-equivalent jurisdictional fight. That clarity took years of court cases and legislative action. The US is now retracing that path with the added complication that the federal derivatives regulator is also asserting jurisdiction. Expect resolution to take longer in the US than it did in Europe.
#regulation
#policy
Related